425 Settlers Way, Gray, TN 37615

$825,000

Some homes check the boxes. Others redefine how you live. Welcome to 425 Settlers Way, where thoughtful upgrades, flexible living space, & a setting that actually gives you room to breathe come together in a way that just feels right. Situated on an oversized ~0.8 acre lot in one of… Read More Gray's most desirable pockets, this home delivers something increasingly rare: true main-level living paired with meaningful square footage that adapts to your life. Step inside & you'll feel the flow immediately. The main living area (where a cozy fireplace adds warmth & character) opens seamlessly into the kitchen & dining space, anchored by a large island designed for real life: morning routines, catch-ups, & everything in between. Updated appliances (2020), a farmhouse sink, & clean finishes bring both style & function, while subtle design touches like the West Elm gold finishes elevate without overdoing it. The main level features 3 bedrooms, including a private primary suite with custom barn doors that add just the right amount of character. Everything about this level is designed for ease, comfort, & everyday livability. But this home doesn't stop at the main level, it expands in both directions, upstairs & down, each offering its own fully functional spaces. Upstairs, a F.R.O.G. (Finished Room Over Garage) is a true ensuite setup with full bath, closet, & bedroom, perfect for guests, a private office, or a tucked-away retreat. Just off this space, you'll find hundreds of square feet of walkout attic storage, giving you easy-access, highly usable space that's rarely found in most homes. Downstairs is where the opportunity really opens up. Finished just 2 years ago, the lower level, thoughtfully designed with separate entrance, has generated rental income. Complete with its own kitchenette (fridge, range, microwave, sink), full bath, bedroom, living room, gym w/mirrors (easily a 2nd bedroom), almost 200 sq ft of unfinished storage, & a dedicated garage ideal for storing everything from tools to toys: this level works for multi-generational living, income potential, or for giving everyone their own space. Step outside to the lower patio & you've got a completely separate living experience. Altogether, this home offers the potential for up to 6 bedrooms across all levels, without ever feeling cramped. Multiple living zones create separation when you want it, while still keeping everyone connected when it matters most. And then there's the outside. The backyard has been intentionally reworked to create usable, flat space, complete with a retaining wall with stone end caps, a firepit area that's ready for evenings with friends, & nights that linger longer. A full irrigation system keeps everything looking its best. A covered deck (almost 270 sq ft) extends your living space outdoors, with seamless indoor-outdoor flow, making it just as functional as the inside. Now layer in the seller's upgrades that make everyday living not just easier, but smarter. Solar panels installed in 2022 through Greene Tech work quietly in the background to offset energy costs, while the EV charger (tied directly into that solar system) positions the home for where things are going. A Nest thermostat brings modern control & efficiency to your comfort, & a 500-gallon propane tank fuels the range, water heater, & outdoor grill, giving you both performance & reliability where it matters most. Even the garage has been thoughtfully considered, with built-in shelving that will remain, because storage isn't just about space, it's about usability. And the location ties it all together. This is why people choose Gray: 19min to Johnson City Med Center, 19min to Eastman HQ, 12min to TRI, & 10min to Boone Lake. All while still enjoying privacy that's hard to find. This isn't just a house with space, it's a home with options. Live on the main. Host upstairs. Income downstairs. Or simply spread out & enjoy it all. Info deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyer/Buyer Agent to verify Read Less

Courtesy of Ryan & Sarah McKinney, KW Johnson City 423-773-1607.

Listing Snapshot

Days Online

Last Updated

Apr 5, 2026

Property Type

Single Family

Beds

Full Baths

Square Ft.

4,752

Lot Size

0.8 Acres

Year Built

2013

MLS Number

9993219

30 Days Snapshot Of 37615

$424k

+11%

(avg) sold price

-8%

homes sold

101

+9%

(avg) days on market

Snapshot

Area Map

Additional Details

Appliances & Equipment

"Dishwasher", "Disposal", "Microwave", "Range", "Refrigerator"

Basement

"Block", "Exterior Entry", "Garage Door", "Heated", "Interior Entry", "Unfinished", "Walk-Out Access", "Workshop"

Building

Built in 2013, 1,519 below grade finished area, Building area total: 4,752, Living area: 4,345, Levels: "Three Or More", Architectural style: "Farmhouse", "Craftsman", "Traditional", Construction materials: "Brick", "Stone Veneer", "Vinyl Siding"

Community

"Curbs"

Cooling

"Heat Pump"

Exterior Features

"See Remarks"

Fireplaces

"Gas Log", "Great Room", 1 total fireplace

Floors

"Carpet", "Ceramic Tile", "Hardwood", "Luxury Vinyl"

Garage

2 garage spaces

Heating

"Central", "Fireplace(s)", "Heat Pump"

Home Owner's Association

Association fee: $165, Association amenities: "Landscaping"

Interior Features

"Primary Downstairs", "Entrance Foyer", "Granite Counters", "Kitchen Island", "Open Floorplan", "Pantry", "Soaking Tub", "Utility Sink", "Walk-In Closet(s)", "See Remarks"

Laundry

"Electric Dryer Hookup", "Washer Hookup"

Lot

0.8 acres, 34,848 square feet, Size: 1

Parking

"Driveway", "Attached", "Concrete", "Garage Door Opener"

Property

Patio and porch features: "Back", "Covered", "Deck", "Front Porch", "Rear Patio", Topography: Level, Rolling Slope, Zoning: RS

Roof

"Shingle"

Sewer

"Public Sewer"

Utilities

"Electricity Connected", "Propane", "Sewer Connected", "Water Connected", "Cable Connected"

Windows

"Double Pane Windows"

Find The Perfect Home

'VIP' Listing Search

Whenever a listing hits the market that matches your criteria you will be immediately notified.

Join The List

Mortgage Calculator

Selling price

Down payment

Term (years)

Interest rate (%)

Monthly Payment

Buyers

Sellers

Relocation

Communites

About Us

425 Settlers Way

'VIP' Listing Search

Schools In The Area

Similar Listings

Find My Dream Home

1. Neighborhoods

2. Home Type

3. Send

Ready to make your move?

BUYERS

SELLERS

ABOUT

FOLLOW US